In the WordPress plugin repository, “Email Log” is a popular search term. There are half a dozen free plugins that promise to log your mail. For a hobby site, these are fine. They create a list of emails. But for a business, a “Free” logger is often a false economy. The difference lies in Actionability. A free logger tells you that you have a problem. WP Email Log gives you the tools to fix the problem. In this review, we will dismantle the differences between the free repository plugins and this premium solution to see where the extra value lies.
The “Resend” Gap (Passive vs. Active)
This is the single biggest differentiator.
-
Free Plugins: They show you a list of sent emails. If a customer says “I didn’t get my receipt,” you can look at the list and say, “Yep, it sent.” That’s it. You can’t do anything else. You have to manually create a new email, copy the data, and send it from your Outlook.
-
WP Email Log: It includes the One-Click Resend. You see the failed email. You click a button. It sends again.
-
The Value: This turns a 15-minute manual task into a 5-second fix. If you value your time at $50/hour, the plugin pays for itself after just 4 resends.
The “Silent Failure” Problem (Monitoring)
Free plugins live inside your WordPress site. If your site goes down, or if your PHP mail function crashes, the plugin goes down with it. It cannot alert you because it is dead. WP Email Log includes External SaaS Monitoring.
-
The Watchdog: It uses an outside server to ping your email infrastructure daily.
-
The Alert: If your email stops working, you get a notification on your phone.
-
The Value: Free plugins are reactive (you look at them after a complaint). This plugin is proactive (it tells you before the complaint happens). You cannot get this external monitoring for free.
Visual Fidelity (HTML Preview)
Most free loggers store the “Message Body” as raw text or a blob of unformatted HTML code. Trying to debug a broken WooCommerce receipt by reading raw HTML code is a nightmare. WP Email Log renders the Visual Preview.
-
The View: You see the email exactly as the customer sees it—images, layout, buttons, and all.
-
The Value: You can instantly spot if a broken image link or a CSS conflict is making your brand look unprofessional.
Handling Attachments
Did the customer get the PDF invoice? Did the contract attach to the email? Free loggers often ignore attachments completely or just show a file path. WP Email Log tracks Attachment Status. It confirms that the file was actually handed off to the server. For businesses that sell digital files or send legal documents, this verification is critical for proving delivery.
Security via Off-Site Backups (Auto-Forward)
A free plugin stores logs in your database. If a hacker breaks in, the first thing they do is “Empty Tables” to hide their tracks. Your logs are gone. WP Email Log allows for Auto-Forwarding. By sending a real-time copy of every email to a secure, external inbox (e.g., logs@mycompany.com), you create an indestructible audit trail. Free plugins rarely offer this feature because it adds complexity to the sending process.
Support: The “Volunteer” vs. The “Professional”
If a free logger breaks your site after an update, you post on a support forum and hope a volunteer answers you in a week. With WP Email Log, you have a paid contract with WebFactory Ltd. They guarantee compatibility with the latest WordPress versions and PHP environments. When your email infrastructure is critical to your revenue, relying on “Volunteer Support” is a business risk you shouldn’t take.
Final Verdict
A free email logger is like a security guard who watches a robbery happen but can’t call the police. It records the failure but offers no help. WP Email Log is the full security detail. It watches, it alerts, and it intervenes (Resend). For $59/year, you are buying the ability to Recover lost revenue, not just record it. For any commercial website, that is an easy upgrade to justify.